I know there are many questions that are similar (maybe identical?). I am not a physicist nor a student - I am just interested in physics and have been watching many physics channels on youtube recently in my spare time.
Here is a (nearly) identical question: Why don't electromagnetic waves require a medium?
Here is one response to this question :
Well, I would say the electromagnetic field is the medium.
I don't understand this - How can something be the medium for itself?
The answers to these questions I don't really think address specific points of confusion I am having - so I am going to try to ask the question a little differently
How can light (or electromagnetic radiation) travel through a vacuum when there is nothing there to act as a medium, and do so forever in all directions? For example the light coming from a star millions of light years away.
With water, for example, it is easy for me to see how a wave can disperse over the surface in all directions and travel for as long as the energy in the wave doesn't dissipate. The molecules in the water act as the medium, and are oscillating and pushing all neighboring molecules causing a domino effect outwards.
But what is the light doing?
One thought I had is, if light is made of something then it just moves outwards from the point of origin in whatever direction the light was headed.
Which leads me to photons...
Here is the first paragraph from Wikipedia : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photon
A photon is an elementary particle, the quantum of light and all other forms of electromagnetic radiation, and the force carrier for the electromagnetic force, even when static via virtual photons. The effects of this force are easily observable at both the microscopic and macroscopic level, because the photon has no rest mass; this allows for interactions at long distances. Like all elementary particles, photons are currently best explained by quantum mechanics and exhibit wave–particle duality, exhibiting properties of both waves and particles. For example, a single photon may be refracted by a lens or exhibit wave interference with itself, but also act as a particle giving a definite result when its position is measured.
So... maybe photons make up light, and they are just shooting through space like a wave, but it really isn't a physical wave (like a sound or water wave), it's just "acting like one"?
Here is a video from minutephysics : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_h4IoPJXZw
The video talks about the particle-wave duality of an electron. So a single electron can act as a wave, but when it hits something it hits only one place. Is that the same for photons?
Thought Experiment : Out in the vacuum of space there is a huge hollow sphere 1 light year in radius. Inside is just vaccuum, and at the exact center a flash of light is emitted in all directions from a point source. 1 year later the light hits the sphere at all places at once.
That's 12.6 (or 4 times pi) light years squared of surface area to cover! How can there be enough photons to hit every spot inside the surface area of this huge sphere? I understand that very little light would hit this far away, but even if non-zero at least some light is hitting.
Or maybe does this depend on how big the flash was? Maybe it doesn't hit every spot?
If light really is made of photons and acts like a wave but each photon hits only one place, then it seems to me there must be an infinite amount of photons in that flash of light to hit so many places inside the sphere.
But that must be impossible, so there must be a flaw in my reasoning.
Answer
Well, I would say the electromagnetic field is the medium.
I don't understand this - How can something be the medium for itself?
Light isn't just an electromagnetic field. Light (i.e. photons) is a wave---a disturbance or perturbation---in an electromagnetic field. Just like for gravity, fields apparently permeate space. Even massive particles (e.g. quarks or electrons) can be described (or viewed) as waves in underlying fields.
So... maybe photons make up light, and they are just shooting through space like a wave, but it really isn't a physical wave (like a sound or water wave), it's just "acting like one"?
What you're calling a 'physical wave' is an emergent property of a underlying medium (e.g. air, water). For the most part, such an emergent wave is basically the same as a wave in a field. 'Physical waves' are often referred to as 'quasiparticles', because of this similarity. What we think of as 'particles' (e.g. electrons) don't just 'behave like waves', they are also waves, hence the 'wave-particle duality'.
No comments:
Post a Comment