Tuesday, December 29, 2015

differential geometry - How can I trace the path of a photon on space-time defined by this metric?


I have a hypothetical universe where the relation between space and time is defined by this metric:


ds2=ϕ2dt4+dx2+dy2+dz2 Where ϕ=1.94×1014 km s2 (note that all terms are rank-2 differential form). Ignoring one of the dimensions of space, the surface of this space-time looks like this: Hypothetical Universe after 6 months



I would like to describe how a photon of light travelling at c would travel on this surface, but I lack the basic skills to perform the operation using differential geometry. Note that the size of the universe is accelerating with the passage of time. I know it can be done using integration, geometry and a lot of algebra, but I'm looking for a more elegant way to solve it using the metric.


My question is, if I know the current time and the amount of time the photon has been travelling at c, can I calculate the amount of space it's traveled?



Answer



First, your metric must be corrected to be rank-2. Evidently you are trying to write a metric for the universe expanding with the acceleration ϕ rϕt2


Your corrected metric equation would be


ds2=ϕ2t2dt2+dr2


Where


dr2dx2+dy2+dz2


Null geodesics (trajectories of light) would be found by setting ds=0


r=ϕ2(tto)2



As you can easily see, for ϕ=0 time in this universe stops. A better metric is


ds2=(ϕt+c)2dt2+dr2


With the trajectories of light given by


r=c(tto)+ϕ2(tto)2


Where r(to) and to are the coordinates of the light emission event and the negative solution is dropped as the time reversal. The coordinate distance r traveled by light is


r=x2+y2+z2


EDIT based on OP's requirements in the comments



The features that need to be captured are


A) x=ϕt2 (the diameter of the universe is proportional to the square of the time)



B) The space is closed (travel far enough in a straight line and you arrive where you started)


C) A metric that can be compared to FLRW, and hopefully one that provides a differential solution for the path of a photon



We start with a generic metric for an expanding space assuming its homogeneity and isotropy


ds2=c2dt2+a(t)2dΣ2


Where Σ ranges over a 3-dimensional space of a uniform positive curvature and a(t) is a scale factor. According to the requirement (A) where ϕ is acceleration


r=ϕ2t2


While the topology of this space may vary, the requirement (B) along with OP's comments and chart imply that the space is a 3-sphere S3 whose round metric in the hyperspherical coordinates is


dΣ2=r2dΩ2


Where



dΩ2=dψ2+sin2ψ(dθ2+sin2θdφ2)


Combining the formulas we obtain the final metric


ds2=c2dt2+(ϕ2t2)2dΩ2


The null geodesics equation is ds=0 or for θ=φ=0


2cϕdtt2=±dψ


Solving for the path of the photon


ψ=ψo±2cϕ(1to1t)


We can set ψo=0 by the choice of coordinates and drop the negative direction


ψ=2cϕ(1to1t)


Where t is the current age of the universe and to is the age of the universe at the moment of the emission of the photon. Here ψ represents the arc angle of the photon traveling around the expanding hypersphere of the universe. A full round trip is ψ=2π



2π=2cϕ(1to1t)


By solving for t we obtain the time tr=t2πto required for the round trip


tr=t2otto


Where t is the age of the universe, after which a round trip at the speed of light is no longer possible, because the universe is expanding too fast


t=cπϕ


Finally, for the requirement (C), this metric essentially is in the same form as FLRW, just with a different scale factor, so comparing them should be pretty straightforward.


EDIT - The Hubble Law


The instantaneous (t=const.) local coordinate x distance along the direction of ψ from a chosen location at xo=0 is


x=ψr


Where r is the current radius of the universe and ψ=const. in the expansion. We can define the recession speed of the point x relative to xo as



v=dxdt=ψdrdt=ψϕt=2xt


Where t is the current age of the universe. Thus the Hubble law is


v=Hx=2xt


With the Hubble parameter showing the age of the universe as double the Hubble time


H=2t


The radius of the observable universe (cosmic horizon) at the time to is the distance, from which the photons will never reach back. From the path of the photon above for t= we have


x=ψr=2crϕto=cto


Which matches the intuition. The radius of the universe when at t it becomes larger than the observable universe


r=c22π2ϕ=ϕ2t2


No comments:

Post a Comment

classical mechanics - Moment of a force about a given axis (Torque) - Scalar or vectorial?

I am studying Statics and saw that: The moment of a force about a given axis (or Torque) is defined by the equation: $M_X = (\vec r \times \...