Tuesday, December 15, 2015

electromagnetism - Is there a relationship between the energy of a photon and the energy of an electromagnetic wave?


If the energy of a photon


Ep=hv


And the energy of an electromagnetic wave is


EwˆB2


What is the relationship between Ew and Ep?




Answer



You only need to rewrite B and E in terms of field Aμ (here =c=1), ˆB=[׈A],ˆE=ˆAtˆA0, which is written as infinite "sum" of photons: Aμ=λd3p(2π)32Epeλμ(p)(ˆaλ(p)eipx+ˆaλ(p)eipx). After that you can easily obtain the relation between energies of sets of photons and "real" EM field: ˆH=ˆT00d3r=12(ˆB2+ˆE2)d3r.


If you need I'll derive it.


Tedious derivation


For simplicity you need Coulomb gauge A0=0,(A)=0 (eq. (3) already implies that), polarization sum rule and orthogonality relations for polarization vectors, λeλi(p)eλj(p)=δij,(eλ(p)eλ(p))=δλλ. and commutation relations [ˆaλ(p),ˆaλ(k)]=δλλδ(pk),[ˆaλ(p),ˆaλ(k)]=0. First let's calculate (1) by using (2) (Ep=p0): ˆE(x)=0ˆA(x)=iλd3p2(2π)3eλ(p)Ep(ˆaλ(p)eipxˆaλ(p)eipx), ˆB(x)=[׈A]=iλd3p(2π)32Ep[p×eλ(p)](ˆaλ(p)eipxˆaλ(p)eipx). Then d3rˆE2=λ,λd3rd3pd3k(2π)32EpEk(eλ(p)eλ(k))× ×(ˆaλ(p)eipxˆaλ(p)eipx)(ˆaλ(k)eikxˆaλ(k)eikx)=|1(2π)3dinxd3r=δ(n)ein0x0|= =λ,λ12d3pd3kEpEk(eλ(p)eλ(k))× ×δ(p+k)(eix0(k0+p0)ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(k)+eix0(k0+p0)ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(k))+ +λ,λ12d3pd3kEpEk(eλ(p)eλ(k))× ×δ(pk)(eix0(k0p0)ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(k)+eix0(k0p0)ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(k))= =12λ,λd3pEp(eλ(p)eλ(p))(e2ip0x0ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)+e2ix0p0ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p))+ +12λ,λd3pEp(eλ(p)eλ(p))(ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)+ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)). The same thing with d3rˆB2 by using relation ([p×eλ(p)][k×eλ(k)])=(pk)(eλ(p)eλ(k))(peλ(p))(keλ(k))= =(pk)(eλ(p)eλ(k)) can give d3rˆB2= =12λ,λd3pEp(eλ(p)eλ(p))(e2ip0x0ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)+e2ix0p0ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)) +12λ,λd3pEp(eλ(p)eλ(p))(ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)+ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)). So after summation of (4),(5) you will get that ˆH=12λ,λd3p(eλ(p)eλ(p))Ep(ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)+ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p))= 12λd3pEp(ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)+ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p))=λd3pEp(ˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p)+δ(0)). Eq. 6 implies "representation" of the energy of EM field as sum of energies of photons (Ep=ωp), because d3pˆaλ(p)ˆaλ(p) refers to the particles number operator.


No comments:

Post a Comment

classical mechanics - Moment of a force about a given axis (Torque) - Scalar or vectorial?

I am studying Statics and saw that: The moment of a force about a given axis (or Torque) is defined by the equation: $M_X = (\vec r \times \...