If object A is moving at velocity v (normalized so that c=1) relative to a ground observer emits object B at velocity w relative to A, the velocity of B relative to the ground observer is v⊕w=v+w1+vw
As expected, v⊕1=1, as "nothing can go faster than light".
Similarly, v⊕−1=−1. (same thing in the other direction)
But what if object A is moving at the speed of light and emits object B at the speed of light in the exact opposite direction? In other words, what is the value of 1⊕−1? Putting the values in the formula yields the indeterminate form 00. This invites making sense of things by taking a limit, but lim is not well-defined, because the limit depends on the path taken.
So what would the ground observer see? Is this even a meaningful question?
Edit: I understand 1 \oplus -1 doesn't make sense mathematically (thought I made it clear above!), I'm asking what would happen physically. I'm getting the sense that my fears were correct, it's physically a nonsensical situation.
No comments:
Post a Comment