Thursday, March 29, 2018

general relativity - Why does time stop in black holes?


Everyone says that time stops in the black hole. It's a "fact". However, I have never heard everyone explaining that.



Of course, I know that observer in weaker gravitational field sees that something in stronger gravitational field is experiencing slower time. However, slower and no at all is quite different.


I have no idea what equation is used to calculate dime dilatation, but it will use gamma and therefore division. And the only time division of non-zero constant yields zero is when you divide by infinity.


And although black holes are super heavy, super badass and super black, they posses finite energy and therefore finite gravitational acceleration (even at event horizon).


So shouldn't just the time be very slow, rather than just stop from our point of view?



Answer




Why does time stop in black holes?



Time according to whom?


The fact is that, in special and general relativity, there is no universal time. Indeed, time is a coordinate in relativity so one must be careful to specify the coordinate system when asking questions like this.



Now, every entity also has an associated proper time which is not a coordinate which means that it is coordinate independent (invariant). Think of your proper time as the time according to your 'wrist watch'.


In the context of the static black hole (Schwarzschild black hole) solution, there is a coordinate system (Schwarzschild coordinates) that we can associate with the observer at infinity. That is to say, the coordinate time corresponds to the proper time of a hypothetical entity arbitrarily far from the black hole.


In this coordinate system, we can roughly say that the coordinate time 'stops' at the event horizon (in fact, there is no finite value of this coordinate time to assign to events on the horizon).


However, there are coordinate systems with finite coordinate time at the horizon, e.g., Kruskal-Szekeres coordinates.


Moreover, for any entity falling freely towards the horizon, the proper time does not 'stop'. Indeed, the entity simply continues through the horizon towards the 'center' of the black hole and then ceases to exist at the singularity.


We interpret the fact that the Schwarzschild coordinate time does not extend to the horizon as follows: no observer outside the horizon can see an entity reach (or fall through) the horizon in finite time. This is simply understood as the fact that light emitted from (or inside) the horizon cannot propagate to any event outside the horizon.


Why? Because the spacetime curvature at the horizon is so great that there is no light-like world line the extends beyond the horizon. Indeed, the horizon is light-like. A photon emitted 'outward' at the horizon simply remains on the horizon.


Within the horizon, the spacetime curvature is such that there are no world lines that do not terminate on the singularity - the curvature is so great within the horizon that the future is in the direction of the singularity.


No comments:

Post a Comment

classical mechanics - Moment of a force about a given axis (Torque) - Scalar or vectorial?

I am studying Statics and saw that: The moment of a force about a given axis (or Torque) is defined by the equation: $M_X = (\vec r \times \...