Wednesday, October 30, 2019

optics - Could the sky on a planet theoretically be any color?


The sky on the Earth is blue. Could the color of the sky on a planet with an atmosphere be of any color theoretically?



Which colors are the most likely?


I think it would be really awesome to have a planet with a green sky, or a red sky. What conditions would have to be in place for this to happen?


By the way I suspect its impossible for the sky to be white, black, grey, or brown, but maybe this is possible if not at all times during the day, a part of the day?


Does the answer depend on whether the planet is a gas planet or a rocky one? Initially I had in mind a rocky planet, but I suspect a gas planet allows you to cheat a little because gases can be a variety of colors (red even?).



Answer



This is an extremely hard question to answer definitely; its answer is heavily dependent on three things (1) the makeup of the atmosphere in question (2) the density of the atmosphere in question and (3) the surface temperature, and therefore the spectrum of output light, of the star in question.


If the atmopsphere's gasses are themselves are coloured (e.g. $N\,O_2$), then such gasses can clearly shift an atmosphere's colour greatly. In low density atmospheres, such as that of Mars, dust and matter swept up from the surface dominates, giving the sky a "butterscotch" colour. We clearly need to know what's floating around, so we can't say much more about point (1), so I shall now assume in this answer that the gasses in the atmosphere themselves are uncoloured.


In this case, the dominant effect setting the colour is Rayleigh Scattering. This is the diffraction of light from smaller-than-wavelength inhomogeneities in the atmosphere. When you "see" the atmosphere, you are seeing scattered, not direct light from the sun in question, and Rayleigh scattering happens most strongly at shorter wavelengths. It is a powerful effect: in the small inhomogeneity limit, it varies as the inverse fourth power of the wavelength. So the process always favours shorter wavelengths.


This means that for a sun of similar spectrum to ours, and in an atmospheric density like ours, the sky will be blue, like ours, or like Jupiter's (in the upper layers). However, for very high density atmospheres, the direct light reaching the surface has its shorter wavelengths heavily attenuated by Rayleigh scattering, so that only longer wavelengths reach the surface. It is for this reason that pictures taken by Russia's Venera landers on Venus suggest that the sky has an orange glow.


If the planet is orbitting a red giant, I am guessing this would probably mean a greenish or yellow sky for a planet with an atmospheric density like ours, as the spectrum of the star's light contains only longer wavelengths than that from our Sun. However, the inverse fourth power dependence means that now the glow from the atmospheric gasses themselves is much weaker, so the sky's colour is more likely to be dominated by things like dust, as in the case of Mars.



No comments:

Post a Comment

classical mechanics - Moment of a force about a given axis (Torque) - Scalar or vectorial?

I am studying Statics and saw that: The moment of a force about a given axis (or Torque) is defined by the equation: $M_X = (\vec r \times \...