I am working through Ch. 3 of Ballentine where he finds the commutator relationships between various operators.
He begins on p.78 with a space displacement
x′=x+a
Which involves a corresponding displacement of position eigenvectors
|x′⟩=e−ia⋅P/ℏ|x⟩=|x+a⟩.
However, I believe it should be instead
|x′⟩=e−ia⋅P/ℏ|x⟩=|x−a⟩.
Because, he mentions that we are taking the "active" point of view, where we keep the coordinates the same but instead shift our vectors and operators. In this case, |x′⟩ is shifted +a which in turns means that it is equal to unprimed position eigenvector −a.
Answer
After going through the text again, I wanted to give an answer more motivated by the exposition in the text.
From, p.63, since the laws of nature are invariant under certain space-time transformations, if A|ϕn⟩=an|ϕn with A representing an observable, and ϕn an eigenvector, then after the transformation A′|ϕ′n⟩=an|ϕ′n⟩ because they represent the same observable.
And from p.64 and p.65, given a space-time transformation U
|ϕ′n⟩=U|ϕn⟩
A′=UAU−1
Now, for a space displacement of the position operator we have |x′⟩=e−ia⋅P|x⟩=|x+a⟩
Which suggests, Q′=Q−aI
So, thinking back to the active/passive view of transformations where I was confused, what is happening is that we are shifting the position operator Q forward by a which corresponds to an active point of view.
This results in the position eigenvectors for a specific eigenvector to be shifted forward or in other words for the eigenvalues of a given eigenvector to be shifted backwards! All very confusing, but I believe this clarifies my original question more in the spirit of the text exposition.
No comments:
Post a Comment